My first pregnancy I had the All Nighter and liked it, but felt the long/wide bottom was too cumbersome for my 5'5" frame. For my second pregnancy I tried a couple Amazon pillows that never had enough cushion or length. I decided to spring for another LeachCo and went with Split Decision. It was AMAZING my entire pregnancy, I brought it everywhere - including in it's own suitcase on a bachelorette party! So needless to say I ordered it as soon as I found out I was pregnant with my 3rd. I generally have hip and back pain which is exacerbated by pregnancy, even in the early weeks and this helps me sleep so much better! I also used it postpartum after my C-Section to help sleep in an elevated position to alleviate pain when getting up to get the baby at night. Such a great pillow!